Insurance is designed to provide financial protection against risks, whether from accidents, property damage, health issues, or business liabilities. However, sometimes insurance companies deny valid claims, delay payments, or act in bad faith. When this happens, policyholders may need to take legal action against these companies.
But who exactly handles lawsuits against insurance companies? What kind of lawyer do you need to sue an insurance company? This comprehensive guide will explore the types of lawyers who sue insurance companies, what kinds of cases they handle, how they work, and what you should know before hiring one.
Understanding Insurance Disputes and Why Lawsuits Occur
Before diving into lawyer types, it’s helpful to understand why policyholders sue insurance companies.
Common Reasons for Suing Insurance Companies
- Claim Denial: When insurers wrongfully deny valid claims for coverage or benefits.
- Bad Faith Practices: When insurance companies act in bad faith, such as unreasonable delay in claim processing, lowball offers, or failure to investigate claims properly.
- Disputes Over Coverage: Conflicts about whether certain damages or losses are covered under a policy.
- Claim Underpayment: When an insurer pays less than what the policyholder is entitled to.
- Policy Cancellation or Non-Renewal: When companies wrongfully cancel or refuse to renew policies.
- Breach of Contract: Insurance contracts are legally binding, and breach may lead to lawsuits.
When policyholders face these issues, they often seek legal help to enforce their rights and hold insurers accountable.
What Type of Lawyer Sues Insurance Companies?
The type of lawyer you need depends on the nature of your dispute with the insurance company. Generally, lawyers who sue insurance companies fall under the category of insurance litigation attorneys, but here’s a detailed breakdown:
1. Insurance Litigation Lawyer
Insurance litigation lawyers specialize in disputes involving insurance companies. They represent policyholders or businesses suing insurers for claim denials, bad faith, or contract disputes.
Key Responsibilities:
- Review insurance policies and claim histories.
- Evaluate whether an insurance company has acted improperly or unlawfully.
- File lawsuits on behalf of clients against insurance companies.
- Negotiate settlements or represent clients in court.
- Handle complex litigation involving insurance law.
Typical Cases Handled:
- Denied or delayed claims (auto, home, health, life insurance)
- Bad faith insurance practices
- Disputes over policy coverage
- Unfair claims settlement practices
2. Personal Injury Lawyer
In cases where insurance companies deny or underpay claims related to personal injury (e.g., car accidents, slip and fall), you may need a personal injury attorney.
Why?
- Personal injury lawyers specialize in representing clients injured in accidents.
- They often deal directly with insurance companies, especially auto or liability insurers.
- They understand how to maximize compensation and negotiate with insurers.
- If insurance companies act unfairly in paying claims related to injuries, personal injury lawyers may sue on behalf of clients.
3. Bad Faith Insurance Lawyer
A bad faith insurance lawyer specifically handles claims where insurance companies violate their duty of good faith and fair dealing. These lawyers focus on holding insurers accountable for unfair claim practices.
Bad faith claims might include:
- Denying claims without proper investigation
- Unreasonable delays in processing claims
- Lowballing settlement offers
- Misrepresenting policy terms
This type of lawyer often sues insurance companies not only for the denied claim amount but also for additional damages caused by bad faith conduct.
4. Commercial Litigation Lawyer
If a business or corporation has a dispute with an insurance company over commercial insurance policies (such as property, liability, or business interruption insurance), a commercial litigation attorney may be required.
They handle complex insurance disputes involving:
- Large-scale claims
- Policy interpretation issues
- Coverage disputes in commercial insurance policies
- Multi-party litigation involving insurers
5. Property Damage Lawyer
For claims related to property damage (e.g., homeowners’ insurance, hurricane damage, fire loss), a property damage lawyer or a lawyer specializing in insurance claims for property losses can assist in suing insurance companies that deny or underpay such claims.
6. Consumer Protection Lawyer
In some cases, if an insurance company’s conduct violates consumer protection laws (such as unfair or deceptive practices), a consumer protection attorney may also be involved in suing insurance companies.
How Do These Lawyers Sue Insurance Companies?
Step 1: Initial Case Evaluation
The lawyer will first evaluate the insurance policy, the claim, and how the insurance company handled it. This includes:
- Reviewing denial letters, claim correspondence, and evidence.
- Determining if there was bad faith or breach of contract.
- Assessing potential damages and chances of success.
Step 2: Demand Letter and Negotiations
Before filing a lawsuit, many lawyers send a demand letter to the insurance company demanding payment or settlement. This can often resolve the dispute without court action.
Step 3: Filing a Lawsuit
If negotiations fail, the lawyer files a lawsuit (complaint) in the appropriate court.
Step 4: Discovery Phase
Both sides gather evidence, take depositions, and request documents. This phase can be complex and lengthy.
Step 5: Settlement Talks or Mediation
Most insurance lawsuits settle before trial. Lawyers negotiate with insurers or use mediation to reach agreements.
Step 6: Trial
If no settlement is reached, the case proceeds to trial where the lawyer presents evidence and arguments.
Step 7: Judgment or Appeal
The court issues a judgment. Either party may appeal unfavorable decisions.
What to Look for When Hiring a Lawyer to Sue an Insurance Company
Experience in Insurance Litigation
Choose a lawyer who has a proven track record of suing insurance companies and winning or settling cases favorably.
Knowledge of Insurance Law
The lawyer should understand insurance policies, state regulations, and bad faith laws.
Client Reviews and Reputation
Check testimonials, reviews, or referrals to find trustworthy lawyers.
Communication and Transparency
Your lawyer should explain the process clearly and keep you updated.
Fee Structure
Many insurance litigation lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they get paid only if you win or settle.
Important Legal Concepts in Lawsuits Against Insurance Companies
Bad Faith Insurance
An insurer’s duty of good faith and fair dealing means they must process claims fairly and promptly. Bad faith occurs when insurers violate this duty.
Breach of Contract
An insurance policy is a contract. If insurers refuse to pay valid claims, it’s a breach.
Statute of Limitations
There is a limited time after a claim denial to sue. This varies by state, so timely legal action is critical.
Challenges When Suing Insurance Companies
- Insurance companies have large legal teams and resources.
- Proving bad faith can be complex and requires strong evidence.
- Laws and regulations differ by state.
- Litigation can be costly and time-consuming.
Tips for Policyholders Dealing With Insurance Disputes
- Keep thorough records of all communication with your insurer.
- Respond promptly to requests for information.
- Don’t accept low settlement offers without consulting a lawyer.
- Consult a lawyer early if you suspect bad faith or denial without cause.
Conclusion: The Right Lawyer Makes All the Difference
When insurance companies deny claims or act unfairly, knowing what type of lawyer sues insurance companies is crucial. Whether you need an insurance litigation lawyer, personal injury attorney, or bad faith specialist depends on your specific case.
Hiring an experienced lawyer who understands insurance law can help you navigate complex legal battles, hold insurers accountable, and recover the compensation you deserve.
FAQ Section
Q1: Can any lawyer sue an insurance company?
A1: While any licensed attorney can technically file a lawsuit, lawyers specializing in insurance litigation or related fields have the expertise to handle these complex cases effectively.
Q2: How long does it take to sue an insurance company?
A2: Lawsuits vary but can take months to years depending on complexity, discovery, negotiations, and court schedules.
Q3: What damages can I recover from suing an insurance company?
A3: You may recover the denied claim amount, consequential damages, punitive damages (in bad faith cases), attorney fees, and costs.
Q4: Do I need a lawyer to sue an insurance company?
A4: It’s highly recommended due to the complexity of insurance laws and the resources insurance companies deploy.
Q5: How much does it cost to hire a lawyer to sue an insurance company?
A5: Many work on contingency fees, meaning no upfront costs, and they get paid only if you win.
Read More:
- The Pros and Cons of Filing a Case Without a Lawyer in California Courts
- What Lawyer Deals with Car Dealerships in California?
- Understanding Immigration Lawyer Costs in Texas and California (2025)
- Can a Lawyer Help Me Get My License Back in Florida? | Detailed Guide 2025
- Do You Need a Lawyer for a Promissory Note in Florida?
- Do You Need an Estate Lawyer When Someone Dies?